In July, the School of Engineering & Applied Science renamed two of the school’s departments and separated from the Applied Physics Department.
With only 56 ladder faculty members, the small size of the school — under which Yale’s engineering departments are organized — made it less competitive than other engineering schools, Yale engineering dean Kyle Vanderlick said last month. So in order to maximize its growth, she said, the school decided to focus itself more narrowly.
Although Yale engineering pared down its departments to focus on areas where it can distinguish itself, in Cambridge, Harvard’s undifferentiated school simultaneously expanded the number of engineering degrees it offered because of student demand for a greater number of degree options.
But while Yale professors said their school’s structure promotes departmental identity, Harvard professors said their structure allows for greater flexibility to adapt to changing times.
IN THE BEGINNING
Five years after industrialist Abbott Lawrence donated funds for a engineering and applied science school at Harvard, railroad magnate Joseph Sheffield donated money and land to a similar school at Yale, thereby establishing the Sheffield Scientific School. Both schools grew, purchased land, erected buildings and trained students — but both were also eventually dissolved.
For the Lawrence Scientific School, the axe came in 1906, but the school was revived with money from the will of Massachusetts industrialist Gordon McKay in 1918. The Sheffield Scientific School, on the other hand, slowly lost its identity, being formally dissolved within the University in 1945 and becoming the Engineering Department in 1961.
Both remnants, however, came alive in the 1990s. Under the leadership of Harvard president Neil Rudenstine, who served from 1991 to 2001, and Yale President Richard Levin, both universities poured money into their engineering programs. In 2007, Harvard turned its Division of Engineering and Applied Sciences into a school. One year later, Yale followed suit.
After 1961, when University president Alfred Griswold ’29 demoted Yale’s engineering school into a department within the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Yale’s engineering faculty began to form divisions by discipline, which eventually evolved into separate engineering departments — what Yale engineering school dean Kyle Vanderlick called the “natural form” of an engineering school.
ALL EGGS IN ONE BASKET
Putting all engineering disciplines into one department — which Harvard does — would be like having all science disciplines under one department, Vanderlick said. Departments have allowed the faculty to create a coherent curriculum for each discipline, which is important for the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology (ABET) certified degrees Yale offers, she added.
An annual review board checks on Yale’s engineering curriculum, Yale mechanical engineering professor Udo Schwarts said.
With ABET-certified degrees, any employer can look at a student’s degree and know exactly what the student studied, Yale associate dean of educational affairs Roman Kuc said. Currently, Yale offers ABET-certified degrees in chemical, electrical and mechanical engineering, as well as intensive bachelor’s of science degrees in biomedical and environmental engineering.
Harvard’s engineering school, however, has only one ABET-certified umbrella degree in engineering sciences, according to its website. While the school’s degree is differentiated into specific tracks such as chemical engineering, students who choose to pursue an engineering degree at Harvard will receive a degree broadly in “engineering sciences,” Harvard engineering dean Cherry Murray said.
“[Engineering students] have to take more courses than the typical Harvard students, but it’s the bare minimum for an [ABET-certified degree,]” she said.
While the degree is not specific, retired Harvard mechanical engineering professor Frederick Abernathy said, the degree allows Harvard students to explore more areas within engineering and the liberal arts. Conversely, Yale engineering students must fit in all their engineering courses, as well as the distributional requirements — a series of a dozen or so courses all Yale College graduates need to fulfill, Schwarts said. “The ABET degrees are one of the most demanding at Yale,” Yale electrical engineering professor Mark Reed said.
But having a specific ABET-certified degree is more helpful to the student’s future than Harvard’s undifferentiated degree, said Yale chemical engineering professor Eric Altman. Very few employers understand what a generic engineering degree means since they do not look at specific classes, said Reed, who worked at computer technology company Texas Instruments from 1983 to 1990.
Furthermore, Harvard’s lack of departmental differentiation makes it more difficult for faculty to organize themselves and develop curriculum for specific degrees, Yale Chemical & Environmental Engineering Department chair Paul Van Tassel said.
In response, Harvard has created “area deans” to supervise curriculum development for specific engineering disciplines, said Harvard environmental science professor Steven Wofsy, who was appointed an area dean in his discipline July.
“The area deans represent a way to capture some of the diversity without making departments,” he said.
The area deans will allow Harvard to develop degrees that may become ABET-certified, said Murray, the Harvard engineering dean. For example, a biomedical engineering degree will be available this fall, while one in electrical engineering is in the works, she said.
Nonetheless, Harvard’s engineering school will continue not to have departments, she added. Being a single entity allows Harvard engineering to change as society changes rather than locking a set of faculty and resources in departments, Abernathy said.
“I don’t really see a great advantage to a department structure,” Abernathy said.
DEPARTMENTAL DIVIDES
In the 1960s, for example, Harvard used to have a world-famous research group working on soil mechanics and sanitary engineering, Abernathy said. But when those researchers retired, no one was reappointed in those areas just for the sake of continuing research in the field, he said. The result was hiring professors in new areas such as computer science, Abernathy said.
Because department structure tends to lock a set of faculty and resources within a given area, blurred boundaries between disciplines gives him more opportunities to do more interdisciplinary work, he said. Furthermore, said Harvard applied mathematics professor Michael Brenner, not having departments prevents faculty members from fighting for resources. At Yale, however, the dean of engineering assigns budgets to each department based on personnel and need, Yale chemical engineering professor Yehia Khalil said.
A desire to maintain departmental integrity played a role in the debate over reforms in Yale’s School of Engineering & Applied Science proposed in February, said Yale applied physics chair Douglas Stone. In mid-February, Vanderlick proposed to remove people from applied physics and chemical engineering and place them in other departments, Levin said. But after the faculty spent weeks discussing the issue, he added, most of them did not agree with original plan. Ultimately, however, the Applied Physics Department left the School of Engineering to become a department within the Faculty of Arts & Sciences, while chemical engineering remained intact within the engineering school.
Stone added that because it takes decades to build a strong department, applied physics professors were prompted to keep their department intact within the Faculty of Arts & Sciences. No one who has worked years to build such departments and relationships within such departments would want to see their departments dissolved, he added.
TWO APPROACHES, ONE GOAL
Although Harvard and Yale’s engineering schools differ in their approaches, each school has tried to build a viable system for itself, professors said. Being a small school within a liberal arts setting, neither Yale nor Harvard will ever have the same clout as MIT, Brenner said.
But while both schools differ in their approaches, they both desire to be the best in their field, said Peter Bogucki, the associate dean for undergraduate affairs at Princeton’s School of Engineering and Applied Science, another engineering school that operates within a humanities-dominated student body. Every institution will do what makes sense for its needs and priorities at a particular time, he said.
Nonetheless, both Harvard and Yale’s engineering schools have built bridges within their universities — Yale’s engineering program frequently collaborates with the University’s other departments and professional schools, Yale biomedical engineering professor Tarek Fahmy said — and both have achieved successes for their small size. In 2003, Yale’s engineering faculty was ranked first in relative citation impact by Science Watch magazine, while Harvard’s engineering school was ranked 19th by the U.S. News and World Report in 2010.
“It’s important to stress that educators do not think of one ‘system’ or another, and that they do not try to copy what works elsewhere,” Bogucki said. “Every institution does what makes sense for its particular needs and priorities at any given time.”
Pingback: Lompoc Plumbing Contractor License | get contractor quotes()
Pingback: Como Usar El Apalancamiento En Forex | Investing 101()
Pingback: Lompoc Plumbing Contractor License | The Tradies Guide()
Pingback: Cleaning Maid Simple Bozeman | find-jobs . housekeeping jobs()
Pingback: Lompoc Plumbing Contractor License | quotes general contractor info()
Pingback: Canon Eos 1000d Gebraucht Kaufen | Kodak()
Pingback: Como Calcular El Apalancamiento En Forex | Top Stop Picks()
Pingback: Como Calcular El Apalancamiento En Forex | Techniques for Investing()
Pingback: Apalancamiento Forex | Invest in Forex()
Pingback: Harvard University Electrical Engineering Department | listings - electrician jobs()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Course Requirements | auto electrician()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | lessons - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | find - electrician training()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Course Requirements | update - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering | emergency electrician()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | meters - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Yale College Electrical Engineering | offline - electrician courses()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty | courses - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | school - how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | blog - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | electrician school()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Course Requirements | how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Course Requirements | electrician jobs()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty | start - electrician training()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | electrician jobs()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Department Faculty | classes - electrician courses()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty | electrician jobs()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Search | electrician - electrician salary()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | courses - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Yale | electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Faculty Of Electrical Engineering Automatics Computer Science And Biomedical Engineering | find - electrician training()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering | electrician tools()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | courses - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Yale University Electrical Engineering Ranking | tools - electrician tools()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | schools - electrician school()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering | electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Electrical Engineer Salary Texas Instruments | electrics - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Electrical Engineer Salary Texas Instruments | electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Openings | electrician training()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Jobs In Sheffield | electrician school()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | engineer - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Search | schools - electrician school()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | electrical supply()
Pingback: Electrician Courses In Sheffield College | corporate - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | electrics - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Electrical Engineer Salary Texas Instruments | auto electrician()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Companies In Sheffield | offline - electrician courses()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Opening | supply - electrical supply()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | master electrician()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering College Confidential | teachers - electrician school()
Pingback: Harvard University Division Engineering Applied Physics | university - top universities usa()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | web - electrician tools()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | electrician training()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | schools - electrician courses()
Pingback: Cambridge University Electrical Engineering Entry Requirements | solutions - emergency electrician()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering College Confidential | electrical supplies store()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Rankings College Confidential | master electrician()
Pingback: Gordon Mckay Professor Of Applied Physics And Electrical Engineering | rates - approved electrician rates()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | book - handbook of electrical engineering()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | guide for electrical engineering()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | electrical supplies store()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | meters - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Companies In Sheffield | ebook - handbook of electrical engineering()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | electrician training()
Pingback: Yale College Electrical Engineering | top - master electrician()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Ranking | update - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Yale College Electrical Engineering | fast - best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Electrician Courses In Sheffield College | electrician training()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Degree Requirements | news - electrician tools()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | car - auto electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | handbook - handbook of electrical engineering()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | course - how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Ranking Electrical Engineering 2010 | apprentice electrician jobs()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Opening | auto electrician()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Opening | electrician - electrician salary()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | approved electrician rates()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | top - master electrician()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Jobs In Sheffield | electrical engineering()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Us News | news - electrician tools()
Pingback: Harvard University Electrical Engineering Department | car - auto electrician()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Department Faculty | business - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Department Faculty | basics -electrical engineering basics()
Pingback: Ranking Electrical Engineering 2010 | courses - electrical engineering schematic()
Pingback: Yale University Electrical Engineering Ranking | super - master electrician()
Pingback: Best Texas Electrical Engineering Schools | units - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | information - union electrician pay()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Ranking | electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | delivery - electrical supplies store()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Mit Curriculum | updates - guide for electrical engineering()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | industry - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools College Confidential | guide - guide for electrical engineering()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | online - electrician courses()
Pingback: Gordon Mckay Professor Of Applied Physics And Electrical Engineering | best -best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Jobs In Sheffield | top - electrical engineering basics()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Opening | pro - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Ranking Electrical Engineering 2010 | best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Intensive Electrician Courses Sheffield | electrician training()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Mit Curriculum | fast - best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | payscales - union electrician pay()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Ebooks Blogspot | corporate - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Schools Electrical Engineering Majors | news - guide for electrical engineering()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools College Confidential | projects - electrical engineering projects()
Pingback: Schools Electrical Engineering Majors | electrical engineering schools()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering | top - electrical engineering basics()
Pingback: Sheffield University Electrical Engineering | find-a-job . electrician jobs()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | electricity - auto electrician()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Openings | electrician tools()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Yale | store - electrical supplies store()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Requirements Classes | jobs - approved electrician rates()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering College Confidential | projects - electrical engineering projects()
Pingback: Ranking Electrical Engineering 2010 | solutions - emergency electrician()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Ranking | best -best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Yale University Electrical Engineering | courses - how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Course Requirements | offline - electrician courses()
Pingback: Cambridge Electrical Engineering Courses | blog - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Faculty | 24hours - 24hr electrician services()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Faculty Position | electrical engineering()
Pingback: Harvard University Electrical Engineering Department | courses - electrical engineering schematic()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | universities - electrical engineering schools()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | electrical engineering()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | handbook of electrical engineering()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty Openings | helicopters -aircraft electrician jobs()
Pingback: Cambridge University Electrical Engineering Courses | meter - electrical supply()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools College Confidential | meter - electrical supply()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | best -24hr electrician services()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | school - electrical engineering projects()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Yale | handbook of electrical engineering()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | supply - electrical supply()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | wages -international electrician wages()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | units - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Cambridge University Electrical Engineering Courses | electrician school()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Faculty | solutions - emergency electrician()
Pingback: Harvard Ocw Electrical Engineering Resourses | read - electrician salary()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | courses - electrician school()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Ranking | electrics - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Famous Quotes On Electrical Engineering | meters - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | news - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Jobs In Sheffield | options - electrician job options()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | guide - guide for electrical engineering()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | electrical supplies store()
Pingback: Abet Electrical Engineering | tools - electrician tools()
Pingback: Yale University Electrical Engineering | business - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Ebooks Blogspot | electrical engineering()
Pingback: Canon Eos 1000d Objektive Kompatibel | Cheap Camera's()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Degree Online Abet | meter - electrical supply()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Ranking | schools - electrician school()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Ranking | business - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools College Confidential | lessons - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | blog - electrician tools()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | electrician -24hr electrician services()
Pingback: Associate Of Applied Science In Electrical Engineering Online | online - electrician courses()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Faculty Position | business - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Us News | courses - how to become an electrician()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Courses In Sheffield | electrician tools()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | salary - electrician salary()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Us News | read - electrician salary()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | job - electrician job options()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | schools - electrician school()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Schools In Usa | web - electrician tools()
Pingback: Electrical Engineer Salary Texas Instruments | tools - electrician tools()
Pingback: Gordon Mckay Professor Of Applied Physics And Electrical Engineering | best - electrician jobs()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | blog - electrician apprenticeship()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Texas | services - 24hr electrician services()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | electrician tools()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Companies In Sheffield | best electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Canon Eos 350d Objektive Kompatibel | All about photography()
Pingback: Canon Eos 350d Objektive Kompatibel | Wedding Photography()
Pingback: Best School Electrical Engineering | courses - electrician school()
Pingback: Accredited Electrical Engineering Schools In Texas | find - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Companies In Sheffield | find-a-job . electrician jobs()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | lessons - electrical engineering()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools In Massachusetts | master - master electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Us News | supply - electrical supply()
Pingback: Canon Eos 1000d Objektive Empfehlung | Photography Spot()
Pingback: Abet Self-study Report Electrical Engineering | wholesale - electrical wholesalers()
Pingback: Gordon Mckay Professor Of Applied Physics And Electrical Engineering | jobs -electrician salary()
Pingback: Electrical Engineering Rankings College Confidential | quick -emergency electrician()
Pingback: Yale College Wrexham Electrical Engineering | start - auto electrician()
Pingback: Best Schools For Electrical Engineering In Usa | master - master electrician()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Ranking | quick -emergency electrician()
Pingback: Best Electrical Engineering Schools Texas | solutions - emergency electrician()
Pingback: Yale Electrical Engineering Curriculum | schools - electrician school()
Pingback: Mit Electrical Engineering Series | jobs -electrician salary()
Pingback: Harvard Electrical Engineering Department | business - industrial electrician()
Pingback: Princeton Electrical Engineering Requirements | schools - electrician school()