DOE cites Yale for underreporting crime, sex assault

The Department of Education has found that the University violated several federal regulations — which include a mandate to report all sex offenses to the government — at the end of a nearly seven year-long investigation into the Yale Police Department last week. Now Yale could face punishment ranging from fines to reduced federal funding for student aid as a result.

According to the DOE’s May 23 Final Program Review Determination, which was addressed to University President Richard Levin, Yale violated the Clery Act when it failed to properly compile and disclose crime statistics. The University also failed to comply with the timely warning and crime log requirements and improperly defined campus boundaries. Additionally, Yale failed to report accurate crime statistics for the Medical School and Yale-New Haven Hospital. Required policy statements were also omitted from campus security reports.

The Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act requires that all universities report their campus crimes annually to the DOE in order to receive federal dollars for student aid.

After completing the FPRD last week, the DOE gave the document to the Department’s Administrative Actions and Appeals Service Group to assess what if any punishments the University will receive for its violations. These could range from a fine to the termination of all federal student aid Title IV grants for the university.

In the report, which was copied to YPD Chief Ronnell Higgins, DOE case director Nancy Giffords wrote that the University had almost entirely corrected the violations since the investigation began in late 2004. Still, Giffords wrote, Yale failed to disclose details from four forcible sex offenses from 2001 and 2002 as required by the Clery Act.

Yale did not include those forcible sex offenses in its report of annual crime statistics when the crimes occurred. Rather, the offenses were only reported to the University’s Sexual Harassment Grievance Board. The DOE determined that all of Yale’s campus crime statistics from several years prior to the investigation only included crimes reported to the YPD, the New Haven Police Department and the Yale Executive Committee (ExComm). Leaving out the crimes handled by the Sexual Harassment Grievance board is in violation of the University’s federal responsibilities, according the report.

Even when the University did add the four offenses to their report, the DOE still questioned its accuracy.

“Yale officials indicated that the [Sexual Harassment Grievance Board] and other such tribunals did not keep any records for most cases and that no one had requested statistics prior to the complaint and the controversies that led to it,” the report read. “For this reason, the Department has determined that the revised statistics are, at best, an unverifiable estimate based on the best recollections of [Sexual Harassment Grievance Board] members.”

Despite the uncertainty caused by Yale’s record-keeping, the DOE review reported that Yale has been in full compliance with the requirements to include all instances of sex offenses in its annual Clery reports for the past six years.

The DOE also accused the University of failing to provide timely notifications to the campus community in the event of crimes. Yale contested this charge, arguing that the claim was solely based on its slow response to an October 2005 attack on a Davenport College student. Still, the DOE refuted the University, explaining that the YPD had failed to give adequate warning following incidents on several other occasions. The report attributed this lapse partially to the residential college system, since information of a crime may only be distributed throughout one college at times.

“The Clery Act requires that reportable incidents that may constitute an ongoing threat must be disseminated campus-wide,” the report read. “However, the Deans and Masters of the residential college limited the distribution of warnings only to members of their own residential college or neighboring ones.”

The DOE also found that the University failed to report all of the incidents on its campus because it did not include crimes occurring near Yale-New Haven Hospital. The hospital is affiliated with Yale and serves as a teaching facility for medical students, therefore some YNNH areas needed to be included in any campus crime reports, according to the Clery Act.

The DOE began investigating the YPD after an article was published in the July/August 2004 issue of the Yale Alumni Magazine. This article, entitled “Lux, Veritas and Sexual Trespass,” raised questions about the University’s compliance with regulations regarding the dissemination of information about sexual assault and harassment, Gifford said in the report.

The DOE first initiated an off-site review of the YPD in November 2004, and then conducted an on-site evaluation beginning June 18, 2007 and ending June 22, 2007.

The DOE investigation only reviewed Yale documents from 2001 to 2006.

Correction: June 1, 2011

An earlier version of this article misstated the nature of the relationship between Yale University and Yale-New Haven Hospital. The University does not, in fact, own the facility, but rather is affiliated through the Yale School of Medicine. The DOE maintained in its report that because of the affiliation and the use of some of the hospital spaces for teaching, Yale was required under the Clery Act to report crimes or crime allegations in certain YNNH areas in its annual campus security data.

Comments

  • Undergrad

    Yale could lose ALL federal student aid? That could cost them about 3 million dollars a year that goes toward financial aid. What would they do then? Would they take it out on the students by reducing their financial aid awards?

  • The Anti-Yale

    Here is the story as I read it from the following excerpts from your article:

    Except for two years (2001,2002) Yale has been in compliance with DOE requirements for reporting sexual offenses for EIGHT of the past TEN years according to a DOE investigation triggered by a 2004 Yale Alumni Magazine article “Lux, Veritas and Sexual Trespass”.

    Is the glass half full or half emtpy? ( 4/5ths full or 1/5th empty)?

    PK

    “In the report, which was copied to YPD Chief Ronnell Higgins, DOE case director Nancy Giffords wrote that the University had almost entirely corrected the violations since the investigation began in late 2004.

    Still, Giffords wrote, Yale failed to disclose details from four forcible sex offenses from 2001 and 2002 as required by the Clery Act…
    The DOE investigation only reviewed Yale documents from 2001 to 2006…

    Despite the uncertainty caused by Yale’s record-keeping, the DOE review reported that Yale has been in full compliance with the requirements to include all instances of sex offenses in its annual Clery reports for the past six years…
    The DOE first initiated an off-site review of the YPD in November 2004, and then conducted an on-site evaluation beginning June 18, 2007 and ending June 22, 2007.”

  • 12

    Yale doesn’t own Yale New Haven Hospital, just fyi ydn

  • Blastoise11

    PK: I think the problem is that the DOE discovered that Yale wasn’t reporting half of what it should before it started the investigation. So it’s kind of irrelevant what they’ve been up to recently.

  • The Anti-Yale

    Bastoise11:

    Sounds to me that once Yale was made aware of its 2001/1 delinquency, it got its AIG pronto and started meeting the requirements as the following 8 years indicate.

    PK

  • ds747

    this has to have been the worst year for yale, ever.

  • The Anti-Yale

    Worst TWO years.

    Just wait a few decades till Global Warming floods New Haven. There will be dykes in the harbor, to no avail. Harkness will be a lighthouse.

  • The_Lorax

    Wow… Yale owns the Hospital? Must be on a secret second set of books that no one knows about. Better get the Feds on that one, too.

    YDN: exposing conspiracies left, right and center. You go, girl!

    What a badly written article. Rambling and pointless. Where were the editors on this? Also I suggest you correct the online article a.s.a.p. It would be a travesty for the above error to be archived as “fact”. If you don’t understand the implications of such an error, then you also have a lot to learn about Yale and New Haven…

  • liuyidaoone

    ( ==== http://www.vogue7.us/ ==== )
    Online Store,Get Name Brand Fashion From 12USD Now!

  • rensheng

    Dear friends, If you find one designer brands shoes online,please look here,we are designer shoes on sale online. Our website: http://www.dswonsale.com
    Designer shoes on sale(Christian Louboutin, Louis Vitton, Jimmy Choo, Chanel) Discount 50%, online price:$110.99-$198.99.
    Brands shoes on sale(Nike,Adidas,ECOO,Supra,MBT,Reebok) discount 45%,online price:$70-$100
    And our company supply clothing,handbags, Accessories for women,men and kids.
    Payment way: paypal,credit card
    All products free shipping for you.
    Hope you order happy in our webstie: http://www.dswonsale.com

  • rensheng

    vibram online for buying:== http://www.fivefingersebuy.com ==
    we have a lots of vibram fivefingers kso,bikila,toe shoes in stock,so buying a vibram fivefingers shoes for you when
    you want to outdoor exercises,you can pay by paypal or credit card,and free and fast shipping for you.
    vibram five fingers hot sale in our website: == http://www.fivefingersebuy.com ==
    vibram kso,(http:/www./fivefingersebuy.com)
    vibram bikila,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    cheap vibram,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    vibram online,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    vibram toe,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    vibram shoes,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    buy vibram,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers toe,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers shoes,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers cheap,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers online,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers kso,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers bikila,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)
    five fingers buy,(http://www.fivefingersebuy.com)

  • rensheng

    http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/ ,this website is ralph lauren shop in UK.
    If you look for a polo now,i sure you can take a satisfied ralph laure polo at
    http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/
    our website supply:
    big piny ralph lauren polo : http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/mens-big-pony-collection-c-5.html
    small pony ralph lauren polo: http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/mens-rl-small-pony-polo-c-4.html
    ralph lauren jackets: http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/mens-ralph-lauren-jackets-c-1.html
    ralph lauren hoodies: http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/mens-ralph-lauren-jackets-c-1.html
    ralph lauren sweaters: http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com/mens-ralph-lauren-jackets-c-1.html
    welcome to ralph lauren online in UK website: http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-shop.com buy ralph lauren goods.
    we accept paypal and credit card, and all ralph lauren will be free and fast shipping to send for you.

  • rensheng

    ED-Hardy shop:
    http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/
    This is ed-hardy shirts,sunglasses,swimwear,bikini sale store,
    you can buy the cheap ed-hardy goods from http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/
    ed-hardy shirts $22.99-39.99 ( http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/ )
    ed-hardy sunglasses $19.99-29.99 ( http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/ )
    ed-hardy swimwear: $21.99-29.99( http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/ )
    ed-hardy bikini: $30.99-41.99 ( http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/ )
    ed-hardy online: http://www.pop-ed-hardy.com/ , send order to buyer with ems,dhl.

  • pppppooo

    Looking forward to your visiting.welcome to our online shop site:

    ————- http://www.wowougg.com
    ————- http://www.wowougg.com
    ————- http://www.wowougg.com

    find your own styles,pick your favorite:
    SUNGLASSES (prada rayben chanel Oakley ) $17-35
    SHOES (Jordan Nike Puma Kobe Gucci) $35-50
    T-SHIRTS (Polo,ed hardy,lacoste) $18-25
    JEAN (True Religion,ED hardy) $30-50
    HANDBAG (Chanel Cocah LV Prada ED) $36-40
    SHOES (Nike Jordan Puma Gucci Prada) $35-50

  • zhonguuk

    very good web: === http://www.goodshopping100.com

    The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike, jordan, prada, also including the jeans, shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.

    All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment., After the payment, can ship within short time.

    We will give you a discount

    WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT

    YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

    === http://www.goodshopping100.com

    thank you!!!

    Believe you will love it.

    We have good reputation, fashion products,

    come here quickly== http://www.goodshopping100.com

    Opportunity knocks but once

  • zhoubapi008

    * ☆ * http://www.vogue7.us/
    * ☆ * jordan air max oakland raiders $30–39;* ☆ *
    * ☆ *
    * ☆ *Handbags (Coach lv fendi d&g) $30
    * ☆ *
    * ☆ *T shirts (Polo ,edhardy,lacoste) $15
    * ☆ *
    * ☆ *Sunglasses (Oakey,coach,gucci,Armaini) $15
    * ☆ *
    * ☆ *Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $20;
    * ☆ *
    * ☆ * New era cap $15 * ☆ *

  • dalet5770

    What is next guards on duty that require all men to perform a sub sadistic ritual in order to gain safe passage

  • amrosca

    So for these mistakes they will lose financial aid … Are they aware that this is actually affecting students the most? I am interested in studying at Yale and I don’t care about either the rapes or the violence (and I am a girl) because to be honest that risk exists anywhere you go. Something like that might happen on the street late at night or in a bar. So why all of a sudden all the paranoid reactions to sex offenses happening on campus? This is just ridiculous …