Morse junior seduces his way to Mr. Yale title

No caption.
No caption. Photo by Egidio DiBenedetto.

If Wednesday night’s victory during the Iron Chef competition was not enough to make Morsels celebrate, they can now also lay claim to this year’s Mr. Yale.

Sudler Hall was filled to capacity Thursday night as representatives of Yale’s residential colleges competed for the title. After an evening of karate demonstrations, glass harp performances and attempts to seduce audience members, Tully McLoughlin ’11 was crowned the victor.

No caption.
No caption.
No caption.
No caption.

Jennifer Ivers ’10 of Timothy Dwight — the first female ever to take part in the competition — was named first runner-up, and Seve Gonzales ’10 from Silliman College took second runner-up.

This year, only 11 of the 12 residential colleges sent contestants. Ben Wescoe ’10, Berkeley College’s representative, told the News on Thursday that he could not attend because of last-minute extracurricular obligations. Still, the competition was fierce as each competitor sought to win over the four judges: Allison Williams ’10, Paul Rice ’10, Timothy Dwight College Dean John Loge and Dean of Freshman Affairs Raymond Ou.

Avinash Gandhi ’10, the master of ceremonies and last year’s Mr. Yale, opened the event by greeting the audience and introducing the competitors’ first performance of the night: an energetic choreographed group dance to Akon and David Guetta’s “Sexy Bitch.” From there, the lights dimmed, and a video projection screen dropped in the front of the hall to display a video compilation of individual interviews with each Mr. Yale contestant. The judges then evaluated them in three categories: formal wear, talents and a question-and-answer session.

The theme of the formal-wear portion of the competition was described by Williams as “the lack of distinction between formal clothing and no clothing.” Branfordian Michael Boyce ’11, walked on to the stage sporting a Branford Snuggie and proceeded to strip to his boxers, while Jonathan Edwards representative Scott Snyder ’10 wore only green briefs that read “JE Sux” in white paint.

McLoughlin, for one, appeared on stage impersonating history professor John Gaddis by wearing white knee socks, a white collared shirt, a blue bow tie, a red scarf, a tweed jacket and no pants. With foam roses protruding from various parts of his outfit, McLoughlin munched on shredded cheese and stared out intently at the audience. Ivers, the runner up, took the stage wearing a three-piece gray suit and a Windsor-knotted tie.

“I’m sorry, ladies, I’m not going to take my clothes off,” she said. “I do have an important lesson for you, though.”

Ivers left the stage momentarily and returned wearing a sandwich board bearing the same text as the one 25-year-old evangelist preacher Jesse Morrell carried when he visited Yale’s campus in December and admonished passers-by to repent for their sins.

The talent portion of the pageant was the longest one of the night and included a short video of Gonzales “ghosting” — creeping up behind unsuspecting members of the Yale community such as the Flower Lady, people running at the indoor track at Payne Whitney Gymnasium and Professor Marvin Chun walking up to the podium before an “Introduction to Psychology” lecture. When Gonzales’ victims did not notice him, he pumped his fist; when they did, he walked away as if nothing had happened.

During Andrés Medina’s ’10 rendition of a now-popular Puerto Rican song called “Nananau,” the Trumbull College section of the audience raised and waved their flag emblazoned with the three-bull crest, and Trumbull Dean Jasmina Besirevic-Regan walked onto the stage to give Medina a mid-act hug.

Saybrook contestant Bryan “B.T.” Twarek ’10 also showcased his musical prowess when he played Miley Cyrus’ “Party in the USA” on water-filled glasses. Twarek rounded out his portion of the talent contest with a synchronized dance with three assistants to the real version of the song.

After the talent portion, it was time for an elimination round that would narrow down the contestant pool to six. When the deliberations ended, the only ones left remaining besides McLoughlin and the two runners-up were Twarek, Richard Ellis ’11 from Pierson, and Michael Gabriel ’12 from Calhoun.

In the final stage of the competition, Courtney Pannell ’11 (who is a multimedia editor for the News) asked each of the remaining six a personal question, such as whether McLoughlin, a frequent initiator of silent raves around campus, has a song in his iTunes library of which he is embarrassed.

“I have some Baby Einstein on my iPod,” he said. “I like to think even a 21-year-old’s brain can still improve.”

The original minute-by-minute Yale College Council plan for the event scheduled Mr. Yale’s coronation for 9:57. But because the first elimination round finished at 10:20, the event coordinators decided to cut the second round elimination and move to a final decision.

Ivers said in an interview Thursday that she did not think she had any advantage or disadvantage competing as the first and only female in the competition. But she added that it is now up to the YCC to decide whether to alter its procedures and make it more accommodating to females who may wish to compete in the future.

When asked after the competition what he would do to celebrate his victory, McLoughlin said he would return to Swing Space to work his weekly shift at the buttery.


  • mc ’13


  • Morse Always Wins!

    Yeah Tully!

  • Sane

    Let’s just say what everyone else is thinking.

    Thank God “Jivers” didn’t win.

    Let’s start with the fact that having a woman enter Mr. Yale is the sort of banal publicity move that the Yale Women’s Center pushes every year. They opposed the creation of a Ms. Yale on the grounds that it would objectify women. Imagine if Jenn Ivers had entered Ms. Yale – she would have demonstrated to the campus that one can challenge traditional gender norms and norms of beauty and what a woman should be. That makes sense. Instead, she entered Mr. Yale because the YCC was too cowardly to set a basic rule: “Mr. Yale is a Yale Man.” The girl is not even transgender – she’s a woman entering a competition designed for men.

    But it doesn’t end there. In the formalwear competition, she harangued a political point that was labored and tired. We get it – the campus preacher is an idiot. Only her adoring fans could think it was possibly interesting to dress up as him for half a laugh.

    In the talent portion, she fenced. She’s a decent fencer, but the performance was more theatrics than actual talent. Unlike others, who sang, played guitar or drums, or broke boards, her ‘talent’ was boring.

    To top it off, her dean was one of the judges. It was patently ridiculous. There was zero chance that she would have moved on had she been a man and had her Dean not been the judge. Zero.

    The event was horribly run apart from Jenn Iver’s participation, but that doesn’t change the fact that women should not be allowed to participate in Mr. Yale any more than men should be allowed to join the women’s fencing team. If you want a Ms. Yale, blame the Yale Women’s Center for torpedoing it.

  • ..

    give it a rest. please.

  • @#3

    If you want to rail about the judges, you should perhaps also note that one of the judges (Allison Williams) is in Morse, the college whose Mr. Yale rep won, and that another judge (Paul Rice) is in Silliman, the college whose rep got second runner up. If you want to complain that Jen only got a place because of the judges panel, fine, but at least carry out your complaint all the way.

    P.S. Fencing absolutely is a talent, just like all other sports. Could you do it? Didn’t think so.

  • Sane

    I actually CAN fence. Did it for 8 years. Like I said – Jenn is a decent fencer, but what she did up on stage was more skit than sport.

    And yes, it sucked that Paul Rice and Allison Williams were both affiliated with colleges, but both Seve and Tully had the audience in hysterics during their talent portions. In my opinion, Ellis (Pierson) and Snyder (JE) got screwed the most by their respective finishes, but my point was about “Jivers”, because it seems like half this article was about her.