You might call it the Great Signature Trek. It’s that time of year when a Yale student searches for offices in buildings he never knew existed looking for a faculty adviser he can barely recognize. After a brief stab at awkward conversation, the student runs out with the adviser’s signature in hand, not to return for another semester.
Advising at Yale is like a disappointing one-night stand: quick and emotionless. We would like to believe each student benefits from the guiding hand of a professor who helps shape a holistic path of study. In reality, too many undergraduates pick their classes with little academic support.
Yale often assumes that creating institutions solves problems on campus. Case in point: Students file a public Title IX complaint. Next thing you know, we have Community and Consent Educators. Same goes for environmentalism and the Office of Sustainability, or diversity and the peer liaison program. Occasionally, these institutions work. More often, they paper over the underlying issues and let us think we’ve found a solution.
Faculty advising is one such broken institution. The administration wants students to make informed decisions about their academic careers. And so we create a position (advisers), a form (your schedule), police everyone to hold all accountable, and we proudly tout our system to prospective applicants. (Preppy-but-peppy tour guide: “Yale faculty are invested in undergraduates, unlike at that school up north.”)
But good advising is more than rote paper-pushing. It requires serious mentorship between faculty and students. It goes beyond shallow questions like, “So, what do you want to do post-college? PhD, med or law?” And a good adviser addresses more than just academic requirements — he or she helps students transition into different stages of their lives. Discussing “Should I go into finance?” requires a deeper examination of what is important: money, family, intellectual fulfillment, morality, to name just a few. A pre-med student asking an advisor, “Should I be a history or bio major?” is asking a question about life goals, not just academics.
Unfortunately, we can’t mandate mentor-mentee bonds. Sometimes it happens naturally, often because of the faculty member’s personality. What makes a good adviser? Part character, part charm and part genuineness. They leave their office doors open and eat every meal in a dining hall. It just isn’t something you can teach. They naturally give life advice alongside the academic.
Freshman advisers are the most variable in quality. Some college fellows enthusiastically embrace their role as a guru-cum-confidant to young freshmen. They take their group of advisees to pick apples and schedule biweekly check-ins. By the end of the year, these engaged fellows know their students as people, not just schedules to be signed. And those students who experience good advising in the first year know what to look for in future advisers. Sadly, many more college fellows disengage themselves from their mentees early in the process, not providing the comprehensive guidance their students deserve. As a result, most of us accept bad advising as a norm, never knowing that good advising can exist.
It seems tempting to burden Yale students with some of the blame here. After all, if students want to talk to a professor, they can go to office hours. But people who need advice sometimes don’t know it. And even if want to seek help, it’s awkward to approach someone who barely knows you for the kind of meaningful advice inherent in every academic question.
Is there a solution to the advising dilemma? Hiring professor who are teachers, not just researchers, might be a good start. Many of the qualities that make good teachers also make good advisers. And pruning the ranks of freshman advisers of the truly detached might guarantee a better experience for clueless frosh. But there likely isn’t an easy panacea. Real steps in advising reform will not be so simple.
For now, we can only confront the facts: the current advising system is broken. Until we agree on the reality, we will keep convincing ourselves otherwise, patting our own backs for our supposedly intimate faculty-student relationships.
Nathaniel Zelinsky is a junior in Davenport College. His column runs on Mondays. Contact him at nathaniel.zelinsky@yale.edu.
Pingback: Binweevils How To Get Mulch Cheat | SOCIAL MEDIA 2016()
Pingback: Cavalier Carpet Cleaning Cairns | carpet - cheap carpet cleaning()
Pingback: Cavalier Carpet Cleaning Cairns | info - cleaning supplies()
Pingback: Forex Confidante Ebook Download | Hot Stock Picks()
Pingback: Best Enlargement Pills Ebook Eng2 Index Funds | Safe Male Enhancement()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch | garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats That Work | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Hack | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch Youtube | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats | decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Xp And Mulch 2012 | garden - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Xp And Mulch 2012 | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch Tastic | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Mulch And Xp | decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Mulch And Xp | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevil Mulch Mayhem Codes | cooch - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevil Mulch Mayhem Codes 2012 | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Download | garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For The Mulch-tastic Ticket | pond - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Mulch Tastic Cheats | Cool Climate()
Pingback: Binweevils Answers For Mulch Tastic | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils 10000 Mulch Cheat | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch And Xp | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Cheats | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats 2010 | multilevel - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevil Mulch Codes Only | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Hack Download | cooch - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch And Xp | pond - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Hack For Mulch | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Mulch | Cool Climate()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats Mulch | hillside - landscape photography()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch And Xp | concrete - gardenedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Hack 2012 | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Answer 2012 | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Answers | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch And Xp 2012 | Cool Climate()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Tickets Cheat 2012 | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Tickets Cheat 2012 | Cottage Garden Landscapes()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat | centre - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevil Mulch Codes Only | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Mulch | Cool Climate()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Today | patio - patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Mulch Tastic Tickets | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch Tastic 2011 | patio - patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat Download | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Tickets Cheat | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Codes For Mulch And Xp | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Mulch And Dosh | elevations - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Xp And Mulch 2012 | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch Youtube | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Xp And Mulch Codes | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Win Mulch Tastic | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Cheats | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch Tastic | sleepers - retainingwall()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat Codes | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For 10000 Mulch | ornaments - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch | retainingwallblocks()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat | garden - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevil Codes For Mulch And Xp 2012 | sleepers - retainingwall()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | patio - patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat 2010 | hillside - landscape photography()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Cheats | patio - patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats 2012 | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Tickets Cheat 2012 | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Codes | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch 2012 | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Dosh And Mulch 2012 | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Giver Download | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker 2012 | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch And Xp | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat Codes | spectacular - amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Hack 2012 | cooch - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Dosh Mulch And Xp | concrete - gardenedging()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch | small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheat Codes | longlife - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevil Codes For Mulch And Xp | spectacular - amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Mulch Tastic Tickets | sleepers - retainingwall()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Dosh Mulch And Xp | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Hack Download | sleepers - retainingwall()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats That Work | concrete - gardenedging()
Pingback: Binweevil Codes For Mulch And Xp 2012 | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Xp And Mulch Codes | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Give Away Cheats | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch And Xp | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Mulch Youtube | landscape lighting()
Pingback: All The Binweevils Codes For Mulch | photography - landscape photography()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Xp And Mulch Youtube | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | lighting - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheat Codes For Mulch 2013 | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Mulch Experience | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Hack For Mulch | garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats 2011 | mediterranean - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats That Work | garden centre()
Pingback: All The Binweevils Codes For Mulch | concrete - gardenedging()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch And Xp | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mystery Codes For 10000 Mulch | gazebo - patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevil Codes For Mulch And Xp | small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Cheats That Work | mediterranean - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes Mulch | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Xp And Mulch | Designer Gardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Dosh And Mulch 2012 | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker Download Plunder | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Xp And Mulch | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Mulch And Dosh | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Hack | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils All Codes For Mulch And Xp | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Cheats On Binweevils For Mulch | hillside - landscape photography()
Pingback: Binweevil Mulch Cheats That Work | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Answer 2012 | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Mayhem Cards Codes | pathways - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For 10000 Mulch And Xp | longlife - landscape lighting()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats Win Mulch Tastic | concrete - gardenedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Xp And Mulch | lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch And Dosh Download | buddist - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Mayhem Wordsearch | thatch - patio designs()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker Download Plunder | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Dosh And Vip Hack Download | centre - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Dosh And Membership Hack Download | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Giver Page | balinese - garden ornaments()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats How To Win Mulch Tastic | retainingwallblocks()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Dosh And Mulch 2013 | multilevel - decking ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Tastic Cheats 2011 | spectacular - amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheat Codes For Mulch 2012 | mediterranean - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheat Codes For Mulch 2013 | garden - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch-tastic Answers | mediterranean - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Hack For Mulch | amazinggardens()
Pingback: Answers For Mulch-tastic | patio ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker 2012 | snipper - lawnedging()
Pingback: Binweevils Cheats For Xp And Mulch | small - small garden ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Hacks For Mulch | garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Codes For Mulch And Dosh | backyard ideas()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Hack 2012 | hedges - garden centre()
Pingback: Binweevils Mulch Maker Download Plunder | spectacular - amazinggardens()
Pingback: Binweevil Cheats For Mulch | landscape lighting()
Pingback: Best Enlargement Pills Ebook Eng2 Index Journal Jobs (November, 2017) - Easy And Safe Male Enhancement()