SCHWARTZ: Our annual nightmare


Halloween on campus is probably the single most distasteful annual occurrence at Yale. In the next two days, students will receive emails from Deans and professional staff desperately warning us to be careful and responsible in our drinking and sexual activity. Nevertheless, Yale Acute Care will add extra staff and prepare for the inevitable and nightmarish inflow of violently ill patients. Multiple people will make mistakes that will likely cause significant suffering to themselves and others.

As with most tragedies and unfortunate events, the harm is all too easy to disconnect from our own experience. Most students’ eyes will glaze over as they reach this sentence; they will discount the kill-joy columnist who seems to be auditioning for a role as the Halloween version of the Grinch. After all, the vast majority of us won’t do anything all that irrevocable in the next few days. And those who do, the thinking goes, have no one to blame but themselves.

This cavalier, dismissive attitude is as self-absolving as it is inaccurate. Halloween is a holiday, and its celebration on campus is a cultural phenomenon. And though the worst of Halloween is experienced by relatively few students, the seeds of the holiday’s destructiveness are felt and created by many more.

For starters, Halloween as a holiday seems utterly meaningless. Other American and Christian holidays celebrate great moments in history, dynamic personalities and actual values. The modern Halloween does none of these things. It is a heavily commercialized ritualization of nothingness.

Perhaps we could hold onto the candy and the costumes of childhood memory. Certainly, there is something beautiful about children’s imaginations coming to life and neighbors visiting one another and sharing food. But these positive and familial Halloween moments barely exist at Yale. Instead of neighbors greeting children with kind words and candy, we have depersonalized masses of students wreaking havoc as they move from suite to suite drinking themselves into oblivion. And instead of using costumes to express magical, childlike fantasies, we privilege the very worst of Halloween’s historical origins: the celebration of the horrible.

Unlike the Celtic celebrants of old, hardly anyone at Yale uses Halloween as an opportunity to worship demonic spirits. Nevertheless there is something demonic about our own modern fascination with terror and pain. Most people who wear bloody costumes and enjoy horror films don’t think of themselves as condoning violence. Yet their actions help create a world in which terror and suffering feel more acceptable. For each axe-murderer that walks by us on Cross Campus on Wednesday night, we become a little more conditioned to violence. We grow a little less viscerally repulsed by evil.

On campus, the problem isn’t simply that the ghoulish aspect of Halloween is privileged, but that the ghoulish becomes intertwined with the sexual. The combination of costumes and alcohol supposedly allows people to give expression to their deepest fantasies and desires. But as the Playboy bunnies and Grim Reapers stream through campus, we have to ask ourselves: what sort of collective fantasies are we expressing and promoting?

Even worse, the violence and the sex are oddly gendered. Nearly every female outfit seems to begin with “sexy.” “Princesses or “fairies” aren’t good enough for a college student; no, only “sexy princesses” and “sexy fairies.” The men, of course, wander around as blood-spattered axe-murderers and Sweeney Todds. So the men are bloody and women are sexy — and everyone of course, is incredibly drunk.

We thus have alcohol, violence and sex being stirred together in one big toxic brew. For some students, that brew will boil over obviously and viciously. But the rest of us should not delude ourselves into thinking that we have gotten through unscathed. The glorification of evil and the gendering of violence and sexuality do subtle but pernicious damage to our way of viewing the world. So dial back the gore and sex. After the YSO show, why not simply eat candy?

Yishai Schwartz is a senior in Branford College. Contact him at .


  • The Anti-Yale

    > and everyone of course, is incredibly drunk.

    EVERYONE? Such exaggeration undercuts the author’s credibility.

  • Jess

    “Unlike the Celtic celebrants of old, hardly anyone at Yale uses Halloween as an opportunity to worship demonic spirits.”

    Here, I think, you have underscored the real tragedy.

  • yale_senior

    Yishai, it seems like you have a particular interest in holidays that don’t aspire to higher purpose, or are devoid of their original purposes, given this op-ed and one of your prior ones about the holiday season. Just a few thoughts: firstly, I don’t agree that just because Halloween is premised on a religious tradition that is very infrequently accepted that that should somehow discredit it. As you yourself admit, holidays such as Hanukkah are equally of negligible “liturgical and ritual significance” are are little more than modern-day inventions. In fact, compared to Hanukkah, I would argue Halloween achieves a greater social good by challenging cultural norms of appearance, a phenomenon that one observes in make countries outside America where Halloween is starting to gain a stronger foothold. But I think that the larger point is that most modern holidays as practiced in largely secular communities do not on a functional level do much in the way of actually commemorating the values or events ascribed to it. Most modern holidays are essentially breaks in our modern routine that provide an outlet for people to come together, and almost always involve some form of excessive material consumption: hence BBQ’s on the 4th of July , turkeys on thanksgiving , presents on Christmas and Hanukkah and, let’s be honest, wine and gafilte fish on passover. Even Ramadan fits this trend, as actually consumption during this period increases in Muslims countries as families and friends host each other and provide massive feasts.

    I think the difference here is that you have essentially judged the “consumption” of this holiday as more base than it is in other holidays, that could be true, but I think that is just an incredibly personal set of standards. While I agree that sex and drinking you describe done in excess can be damaging, I don’t understand this puritanical view that hold that these things which provide tremendous joy should be look down upon with so much disdain. This is not an argument for “if it feels right it must be good,” but instead the idea fulfillment in life comes from much than just the intellectual but the physical as well, and the changes in sate brought about sex and, yes, drinking, can be wonderful things to many. Anyway, just some thoughts.

    • yalemarxist

      See George Bataille on holidays and consumption

  • basho

    Why someone would want to make the halloween choices of others their problem is beyond me

  • Goldsmith11

    candy is bad for your teeth

  • Pingback: important source

  • Pingback: payday loans

  • Pingback: buy cheap auto insurance online

  • Pingback: Rico Whitebread


  • Pingback: cheap arizona auto insurance

  • Pingback: limo hire London , limousine hire London , limo hire , limousine hire , hummer limo hire ,London limo hire , London limousine hire ,

  • Pingback: cash advance lenders

  • Pingback: nj cheap auto insurance

  • Pingback: 1300 numbers australia