Has the idea of a career for which you don’t need an alarm clock ever appealed to you?
The phrase “Yale alumni” conjures images of serious-looking professionals in suits sitting behind unnecessarily large mahogany desks. But what if, despite your Yale education, you don’t want to be a doctor or a lawyer or a business executive? Sure, many a graduate has renounced these stereotypical paths and gone on to teach or work for a non-profit. But you’re a real creative. You want something different.
Have you considered stand-up comedy?
Shaun Breidbart is one Ivy Leaguer who seems to have found the cure to white collar boredom. After graduating from the University of Pennsylvania and working in banking, Breidbart (who goes by Shaun Eli — ironic, he likes to joke, since he didn’t go to Yale), left his job three years ago to work as a stand-up comedian full time. He also founded Ivy League Comedy, an endeavor to bring together freelance comedians with Ivy League backgrounds to perform stand-up shows with an emphasis on clean comedy and smart humor.
“A lot of people dream of quitting their day jobs to be entertainers,” Breidbart explained. “Some of them do it. None of them ever dreams of going back.”
Dan Naturman, Penn grad and occasional Ivy League Comedy performer, had a similar start to his life in the entertainment business. Despite having only limited comedic experience in college, Naturman started going to stand-up shows while attending law school in New York City. Once he had gained experience through bringer shows (open mic comedy nights that allot stage time in exchange for bringing cover-charge-paying friends), Naturman dropped out to pursue a full-time career as a comic.
Having met these comedians in the context of their upper-echelon educations, I had to wonder whether this resume-buffer was helpful or harmful in a world where success was so far removed from a GPA or test score. Is marketing yourself as an Ivy League Comic actually a good idea?
Columbia grad Steve Hofstetter, who has also performed with Ivy League Comedy, seems to think so.
“A comic’s job is to criticize the world in a way that’ll make people laugh,” Hofstetter said. “Figuring out how to observe the world in that way can be something you learn how to do at school.”
Hofstetter added that one of the factors that differentiates comedy from acting is that comedians are both writers and performers. He explained that while many people are good at telling funny stories, being a professional comedian requires a more diverse skill set.
Breidbart and Naturman agreed that even though it may not be your first instinct to associate good performance with a good education, generating material for a routine is a different story. Both men said that it would have been more difficult getting jobs writing comedy if they had not attended elite schools, and Breidbart added that it’s been of use when selling jokes to late-night TV hosts. One of his jokes was on Leno once.
But being a comedian comes with its own challenges. As both Breidbart and Hofstetter explained, serving as your own boss can be a rewarding alternative to a traditional office dynamic, but can also be hard work.
“I’m not just the performer and the writer. I’m also the stage manager, director, contract negotiator and marketing person,” Breidbart continued. “I’d say that comedy is one-third each [of] writing, performing and marketing. And a college degree helps with that.”
Breidbart thinks that having a college degree from a prestigious school like Yale or Penn helped specifically with this aspect of the job, since having contacts from school can be useful in landing gigs at corporate and private events.
However, not all of the comedians interviewed felt like the impact of their Ivy League education on their comedy careers was significant. Aside from writing, Naturman said, he didn’t think his schooling has really been of help, and Hofstetter admitted that he has occasionally run up against the “false notion that everyone in the Ivy League is some pencil-pushing nerd.”
The sting of a silent audience is enough to dissuade the bravest of performers, nerd or not. And while I-banking may offer the money, for these fearless few, it’s all about the funny.